Thinking of Joining the U.S.? Consider What’s at Stake

 

By J. André Faust (Mar 08, 2025)

Canada vs. U.S. Social Safety Nets

Some Canadians, particularly in the western provinces, have expressed interest in joining the United States. However, one important question arises: have they fully considered what would be lost if Canada were absorbed into the U.S.? Beyond economic and political implications, there are significant differences in social policies and protections. The United States, for example, has a strong gun rights culture, which has contributed to higher levels of violence compared to Canada. Before advocating for such a change, it is crucial to examine the differences in social safety nets between the two countries.

1. Health Care

Canada: Universal health care covers doctor visits, hospital stays, and some prescription drugs. No out-of-pocket costs for basic services.

United States: No universal system. Private insurance dominates, and medical debt is a major issue.

Advantage: Canada (Lower costs, universal access).

2. Unemployment Insurance

Canada: Employment Insurance (EI) provides up to 55% of earnings for up to 45 weeks.

United States: State-run benefits vary widely, typically paying less and for shorter durations.

Advantage: Canada (More generous and standardized).

3. Paid Leave (Maternity, Parental, Sick Leave)

Canada: Up to 18 months of paid parental leave, paid sick leave varies by province.

United States: No federal paid maternity leave, sick leave depends on employer.

Advantage: Canada (Stronger worker protections).

4. Social Assistance (Welfare)

Canada: Provincial welfare programs provide income support but can be low.

United States: Welfare (TANF) has a 5-year lifetime limit with strict work requirements.

Advantage: Mixed (Canada is less punitive, but U.S. has more food aid).

5. Education & Student Aid

Canada: Public universities are subsidized, student loans have lower interest rates.

United States: Higher education is significantly more expensive.

Advantage: Canada (More affordable higher education).

6. Retirement & Pensions

Canada: Canada Pension Plan (CPP), Old Age Security (OAS), and Guaranteed Income Supplement (GIS).

United States: Social Security (similar to CPP), but lacks equivalent low-income support.

Advantage: Canada (Better support for low-income seniors).

Final Verdict

Canada has a stronger social safety net overall due to universal health care, better unemployment benefits, paid leave, and a more comprehensive pension system. The U.S. relies more on private-sector solutions, employer benefits, and state-level programs, making support less consistent and more dependent on income or employment.

---